So… Top Chef Masters. Let’s talk about it.
I am a HUGE fan of Top Chef, but then again what Bravo show am I not a fan of? Oh yeah, The Fashion Show is awful. Anyways, I didn’t have great expectations for the show since it wasn’t going to be following the traditional Top Chef formula of following a bunch of wet behind the ears unknown chefs every week forming friendships/love affairs/rivalries all the while competing in some ridiculous cooking competitions.
This time around, each week we have four different famous chefs competing in a quickfire challenge and an elimination challenge where three are sent packing and only one chef moves onto the end of season final championship round with the winners of other weeks.
The problem with this is that we never get attached to any contestant since each week is a different group. Additionally, these are all professionals with reputations to worry about, so there is virtually no drama besides the drama inherent in the challenge. Since the chefs are all more experienced than the typical Top Chef contestant, the food tends to be better which makes for a less interesting episode without any major screw ups. There doesn’t seem like there is going to be any week where Tom Colicchio is like, “You guys were all awful this week and personally embarrassed me!” Speaking of Tom, both he and Gail Simmons are relegated to introducing the chefs at the beginning of each episode… and that’s the extend of their participation unless Gail needs to fill in. The judges are all renowned food critics this time around — luckily without Toby Young on the panel.
There has to be some upsides though, right? Kelly Choi, who I immediately recognized as the host of Eat Out NY who wears too much makeup, is definitely a more competent and credible host than Padme Lakshmi (although I do have some love for Padme). Also, I can’t wait to see what ridiculous hat Gael Green will wear each week.
I’ll continue to watch it since there is really NOTHING on television right now, but this isn’t going to become a favorite anytime soon. Where is the All-Stars Season we’ve all been dreaming of?? — yes, I know there was a single episode All-Stars Challenge but I want MORE.
I’ve actually been quite enjoying Top Chef: Masters. Hubert Keller was precious. I was so glad when the low key chef from Jar won her round. I’ve even appreciated the lack of drama, hissyfits, and whining (then again I’m quite odd and hate most angst, drama, and general awkwardness in TV and movies – I either have to leave the room, cover my eyes and plug my ears, or fast forward.). And I’ve agreed with every winner so far. I hope that Tom Colicchio is participating though because I think it’s definitely time for him to put up or shut up.
However, The Fashion Show, is so, so, bad. I don’t understand why I keep watching it. I hope Anna wins a challenge soon. And whiny Samarai Johnny can leave any time now.
I’m so glad you have a blog, Dan! I’ve loved reading it so far!